This year, we’ve reached new heights, bringing in more contributors and subscribers, and churning out more content and events than ever before. More importantly, we’ve reached greater clarity about our mission, which we attempted to spell out in the intro to vol. ii of the zine.
The many happenings of this year have strengthened our conviction that the discourse is really f*cked—in part because of inordinate elite control over it, but also because of its being excessive politicized, as well as people thinking in horrifyingly simplistic [algorithmic] terms and resolving to only talk to other like-minded people. We seem to naively ignore the extent to which such atomization and social division—perhaps the gravest of all the dangers we are faced with—nullifies our agency and renders us vulnerable to further control and manipulation…and to being miserable all the time.
Cracks in PoMo has found much consolation and revelry in putting out content and hosting events that aimed to:
give voice to narratives that favor the “particular” and “concrete” over the abstract or global, celebrating the value of roots and that which is “given”
give precedence to matters of aesthetics and ontology (culture and faith) over the purely political
look at controversial issues through (1) an unconventional lens that holds space for nuance and complexity, while trying to highlight the elements within these issues that reflect the most fundamental human needs and questions, and (b) a playful lens that makes people chuckle a little and take themselves less seriously
(most importantly) bring people of a variety of backgrounds and ideological persuasions together, to hear each other’s ideas and just talk about life together. Even if we walked away not fully understanding or agreeing with each other, this disposition toward encountering others is already a powerful means to reclaim our agency, and it serves as a buffer against the threat of social division.
Ultimately, we’ve found that making the discourse more weird allows us to step back, to detach from our “agendas” and see it all—and each other—more clearly.
Allow us to break character for a moment and state in complete sincerity (and cringeness) that we’ve been amazed by how our content and events have allowed us to witness so many “cracks” in the discourse. We’ve met some incredible people, had some surprising experiences, and discovered numerous fascinating insights.
As those who were present at our talk at the Catholic Worker a few weeks ago heard, we are in no way naive about how “useless” the work of content creation really is.
reminded us that writing think-pieces and putting out podcasts and silly memes is not going to change the world. We’d argue that the world will be changed not so much by a noble agenda or project of our own making, but by people with a clearer and fuller outlook toward life.And so, we hope that our little drop in the ocean of the discourse will plant the seed of something novel, of a different way of looking at things…and that it will (in some mysterious way) take root and generate something of genuine value.
A big thank you to all of our contributors and supporters! Here’s to cracking our way through another year!
Pop culture/media
Fran Lebowitz: A Relieving Icon, Olivia Cantadori
Instantaneous: Mapping the Baudrillardian hellscape through Colombia, Florida, Alabama,
A Tale of Two White Girls: Taylor Swift vs. Ariana Grande, Stephen G. Adubato
Beauty Kills: review of Tara Isabella Burton's 'Here in Avalon',
The Bimbo Summit Revisited: on the cult of celebrity, Stephen G. Adubato
Technology v/is Nature: A postliberal reframing of AI,
The Gentrification of the UFC, Alex Blum
Souled Out: R&B’s vibe shift, Brennan Vickery
It’s (not) a Party in the USA, Germán Saucedo
I <3 pop culture, but I'd never expose my kids to it, Stephen G. Adubato
Viva la Paglia, Stephen G. Adubato
Sex/gender
Welcome to the Post-Gay Era, Stephen G. Adubato
The Unironic Tradwife, Emilia Tanu
"[Don't] Call Me Daddy": Manosphere influencers are not your father,
contra divorce, the nuclear family, and "leaving the nest", Stephen G. Adubato
I'd rather be a tradwife, Stephen G. Adubato
Dolezal Revisited: What gets lost in trans narratives, Stephen G. Adubato
Great Gays are Gone, Stephen G. Adubato
Political/social thought
Elite enclaves enclosed within a wasteland: on Christopher Lasch & Catholic Social Thought,
Old School CST: Beyond Left or Right, Pater Edmund Waldstein + Philip Burnham
American Idol(atry): an interview with William T. Cavanaugh
The real wars behind the culture wars,
The Existential Angst of Catholic Voters, Stephen G. Adubato
A(n un)holy fool's case for 3rd parties, Stephen G. Adubato
Education
Adjuncts in the City: a horror story (?),
The Lost Cause of Academic Neutrality, by Hamilton Craig
[Protest] the real enemy: the collapse of the corporate university, Stephen G. Adubato
Anti-Anti-Bullying, Stephen G. Adubato
Urban/ethnic stuff
The Bronx is Gratuitous, Emilia Tanu
Moving Sucks, Stephen G. Adubato
Religion
Papa Don't Preach [on Politics]: a Jesuit priest on [not] getting political in the pulpit,
In praise of based Anglicans, Stephen G. Adubato
Why I'm no longer Orthodox, Stephen G. Adubato
Why I no longer identify as “a convert”, Stephen G. Adubato
In Defense of Scenester Christianity, Stephen G. Adubato
Keeping the Pendulum Swinging: Zizek, West, and our PoMo religious revival, Stephen G. Adubato
The Dorothy Day Pilgrimage, Stephen G. Adubato
You don't get Carlo Acutis, Stephen G. Adubato
on priests 'coming out', Stephen G. Adubato
Beyond the pro/anti-Francis paradigm, Stephen G. Adubato
'Cabrini,' 'American Fiction,' & the American aversion to subtlety, Stephen G. Adubato
(we need more people to write for us on religion…)
Podcast interviews
Nathan Allebach on walkable cities
Tara Isabella Burton and David Odyssey on the cult of celebrities (Interintellect salon)
Stella Tsantekidou on being a proud Greek woman in England
AJ Fezza on suburbia and ethnic stuff (recorded live on the streets of Newark)
Carlos Eire on levitating saints
Anna Gat on Fellini and the Society of the Spectacle
Joe Enabnit on the manosphere and fatherhood
Gordon Glasgow on being a real writer
John Milbank, Shadi Hamid, William T. Cavanaugh on faith in a globalizing world (Interintellect salon)
Event proceedings (photos + recordings)
is academia dead? (KC Johnson, Hamilton Craig, and Jonah Howell)
Can the Soul Remain Open When Life Settles In?: On the future of Gen-Z (Tara Isabella Burton and Patrick Gilger SJ)
Holy Lit!: Literature and Disenchantment (Tara Isabella Burton, Jordan Castro, and Matthew Binder)
The Incarnation in an Age of Simulation